Coughing or Laughing in Prayer


Q: Is prayer invalidated due to clearing the throat without need (hawking), talking or laughing?

Is this during the prayer itself or only if you forgetfully finish prematurely and remember you require a sajdatul sahu?

A: Yes. Clearing one's throat without need, talking, or laughing which produces 2 syllables or more during prayer or after you forgetfully finish prematurely (requiring you to complete prayer and perform sujud sahwu) invalidates the prayer altogether.

There is a secondary narration from Imam Ahmad that it is not invalidated due to a little talking which is for the benefit of the prayer after a premature salaam. This would be like someone saying, 'we have another rak'ah' or 'you finished early'. This opinion was adopted in al-Iqna and other works.

Source: Hidayat al-Raghib

#HidayatalRaghib #Coughing #Laughing #Hawking

84 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Q: What is the ruling on wiping the face after qunut in witr? A: It is recommended to wipe the face with both hands after the qunut of Witr just as it is after making dua in general. This is based on

Q: Is praying in congregation after tarawih prayer an innovation? A: What is known as salat al-ta'qib is not disliked. Ta'qib is prayer performed in congregation after tarawih and witr. This is explic

Q: If a Muslim is incarcerated and ends up in a small jail cell that has a bunk bed right next to a toilet and sink, and is locked down for the majority of the day (only 1-3 hours of free time per day