top of page

Can the dead Muslims see or hear us?


Assalamu alaykum. Can the dead Muslims see or hear us or know about our state or something similar? I heard something like that and it kinda freaks me out. Can they see us in the bathroom? Please teach me.

Wa ‘alaykum al-salam. In general, yes. The deceased can hear and some say they can see and are made aware of our circumstances. They are happy with our good conditions and anguished with the bad. They know when we visit their graves and hear our salaams. Don’t be freaked out but focus more on the fact that Allah sees all, hears all, and knows all and is having your deeds recorded. Allah knows best.

Source: Sharh al-Muntaha

Recent Posts

See All
How can I be a better Muslim?

Q: What kind of good deeds should one do daily to be considered a good muslim, lately I think that I'm not doing anything as the only...

 
 
 

3 Comments


Aslamulikum sheikh it not correct opinion because i think you take it from kitab ur ruh by ibnul qayim the hadith are muwdu there and daef

Like
Replying to

There's some dispute over whether Ibn Qayyim even wrote that book. If he did, it was likely a very early one.

Like

Jazakallahu khayra - could you provide us with the daleel for this in shaa Allaah?

Like

©2022 by HanbaliDisciples.com

bottom of page